OPINION

The biggest miscarriage of justice in British history?

“Is the post office scandal truly the biggest miscarriage of justice in British history? While the ITV drama "Mr Bates Vs The Pistons Office" has sparked action from parliament, dropping convictions for hundreds wrongfully accused, it raises questions about priorities.”

Diahanne RhineyEditor in Chief

The biggest miscarriage of justice in British history? After the ITV drama Mr Bates Vs The Pistons Office aired, parliament announced that hundreds of post office operators who were wrongfully accused of stealing and fraud will have their convictions dropped to “draw a line” under what is being called the biggest miscarriage of justice in British history.

The biggest miscarriage?

While I agree it is an absolute injustice, the biggest is a stretch. What concerns me is that the post office scandal affected mostly white British people. That doesn’t make it less of a scandal, but it becomes relevant in light of other scandals that still aren’t being addressed.

Serving with the 48th Highlanders regiment in Quebec and Nova Scotia, Daniel’s wartime experiences went beyond the battleground.

The speed at which parliament made this decision after the release of a TV drama has made me really question a few things about the government dragging its feet when it comes to compensation for other British scandals, especially ones that involve ethnic minorities, including Windrush and Grenfell.

In 2018, thousands of British citizens, mostly from the Caribbean, were wrongly detained, threatened with deportation and denied legal rights because the Home Office had accidentally categorised them as illegal immigrants.

Hundreds were denied access to healthcare and benefits and were threatened with deportation despite having the right to live in the UK.

A significant number were even deported to countries they had not lived in since they were children. Many died before the government could contact them to apologise for its error.

Now, almost six years after the scandal came out and 75 years after Windrush Day, hundreds of compensation claims are still pending.

As of May 2023, 302 claims had been sitting in the system for at least 12 months. Calls have even been made to make the compensation scheme independent from the Home Office because now there is such a lack of faith in the system because so many people have died without receiving a penny, let alone justice.

We won’t forget… Paulette Wilson was a loving grandmother who moved to the UK in 1968 and worked in the House of Commons restaurant before she was detained and threatened with deportation to Jamaica.

Wilson passed away suddenly at the age of 64 – having just one month earlier delivered a petition with other victims to parliament urging the government to speed up its pay outs under the Windrush Compensation Scheme.

I was so outraged by the lack of justice and so saddened by her death that I named an award after her at my annual awards event. This is just one of the victims of this scandal that has claimed the lives of so many.

According to the Home Office, the backlog is still sitting at around 3,720 cases. The Grenfell Tower fire exposed serious failures in the safety of high-rise buildings in the UK.

The building, which contained 129 flats over 20 floors, became a blazing inferno, killing 72 people. It was horrendous. Justice hasn’t been achieved yet, as the same “cladding scandal” continues to affect thousands of homeowners.

There are still at least 10,000 people living in tower blocks deemed unsafe. I personally think these make the biggest miscarriages of British history, and yet the government is stirring on their hands.

Watching this post office situation unfold reveals how quickly politicians can change things if they want to… The question is that when it comes to people from diverse ethnic backgrounds, do they actually want to?

“”

Diahanne RhineyEditor in Chief
STARS, STAGE AND SERVICE

STARS, STAGE AND SERVICE

October 22, 2025 Read More
Editors Letter – October 2025

Editors Letter – October 2025

October 17, 2025 Read More
Baroness Howells – A Bridge Between Two Worlds

Baroness Howells – A Bridge Between Two Worlds

October 16, 2025 Read More
The Need for Black Pride in a Hostile Climate

The Need for Black Pride in a Hostile Climate

October 10, 2025 Read More
Editors Letter – September 2025

Editors Letter – September 2025

September 15, 2025 Read More
Global Black Economic Justice Takes Centre Stage in New York

Global Black Economic Justice Takes Centre Stage in New York

September 15, 2025 Read More
Diahanne Rhiney

Co-founder and Chief Editor: A Beacon of Resilience at Black Wall St. Media For those immersed in the world of Black Wall St. Media, the story of its Co-founder and Chief Editor is one that resonates with tenacity, resilience, and determination. Hers is a testament to facing life's adversities and transforming them into a powerful mission that drives the core of this groundbreaking platform. Endowed with a life journey that many would describe as challenging, she has confronted and navigated myriad obstacles, from personal setbacks to professional hurdles. Yet, she has emerged not as a victim but as a beacon of strength and inspiration. A tumultuous past relationship that escalated into a harrowing stalking experience, and the eventual attempt on her life, could have broken many. But for her, it became a clarion call to change, to stand tall, and to make a difference. The untimely loss of her mother, whom she fondly remembers as the 'foundation stone' of her life, further fuelled her determination. Attending a funeral attended by over a thousand individuals mourning her mother, she realized the power of leaving a legacy that benefits and uplifts others. Empowered by her personal narrative and a passion for social change, she delved into the realms of psychology and empowerment. What emerged was not just a survivor but a 'Social Change-maker'. She pioneered the inception of the first Social Change PR Agency specializing in diversity marketing and race relations, thereby cementing her place as a frontrunner in advocating for change. At Black Wall St. Media, as the Co-founder and Chief Editor, she brings this vast reservoir of experiences, insights, and an indomitable spirit. She has transformed the platform into a beacon for those seeking empowerment, change, and a voice. Her role isn't limited to just editorial oversight; she embodies the very ethos of Black Wall St. Media, making it a space where stories of resilience, empowerment, and social change are not just narrated but celebrated. In the corridors of Black Wall St. Media, she stands tall as a reminder that challenges are not setbacks but stepping stones, and that every individual, no matter their past, can be architects of profound social change.

Leave a Reply